Car Insurance Deductible Break-Even Calculator

Compare high deductible vs low deductible car insurance. Calculate break-even point based on accident likelihood and premium savings.

Lower deductible amount (e.g., $500)
Annual premium cost with low deductible
Higher deductible amount (e.g., $1,000)
Annual premium cost with high deductible
Probability of having an at-fault accident per year (typically 2-10% for most drivers)

How This Tool Works

This calculator compares high deductible vs low deductible car insurance to determine the break-even point. It calculates how many accidents you would need to have before the premium savings from a high deductible are offset by the higher out-of-pocket costs. The tool also factors in your accident likelihood to show expected annual costs for both options.

Understanding the break-even point helps you make an informed decision. If you rarely have accidents, high deductible may save money over time. If you have accidents more frequently, low deductible may be more cost-effective. This calculator shows both the break-even analysis and expected costs based on your accident probability.

Formula

The calculations are based on:

Annual Premium Savings = Low Premium - High Premium
Deductible Difference = High Deductible - Low Deductible
Break-Even Accidents = Annual Savings / Deductible Difference
Years to Break Even = Break-Even Accidents / Annual Accident Likelihood
Expected Annual Cost = Premium + (Accident Likelihood × Deductible)

For example, $500 vs $1,000 deductible, $1,200 vs $1,000 premium, 5% accident likelihood:

Annual Savings = $1,200 - $1,000 = $200
Deductible Difference = $1,000 - $500 = $500
Break-Even Accidents = $200 / $500 = 0.4 accidents
Years to Break Even = 0.4 / 0.05 = 8 years
Expected Cost (Low) = $1,200 + (0.05 × $500) = $1,225
Expected Cost (High) = $1,000 + (0.05 × $1,000) = $1,050

Understanding Deductibles

  • Low Deductible ($250-500): Higher premiums, lower out-of-pocket costs per claim, better for frequent claims or tight budgets
  • High Deductible ($1,000-2,500): Lower premiums, higher out-of-pocket costs per claim, better for safe drivers who rarely file claims
  • Premium Savings: Typically 10-30% lower premiums for each $500 increase in deductible
  • Break-Even Point: The point where premium savings equal additional out-of-pocket costs
  • Risk Tolerance: Consider your ability to pay the higher deductible if you have an accident
  • Driving History: Safe drivers with few accidents benefit more from high deductibles

FAQ

  • Should I choose high or low deductible car insurance?
    Choose high deductible if you can afford the higher out-of-pocket cost and want lower premiums. Choose low deductible if you prefer predictable costs and want lower out-of-pocket expenses in case of an accident. This calculator helps you determine the break-even point based on your accident likelihood and premium savings.
  • What is the break-even point for insurance deductibles?
    The break-even point is when the premium savings from a high deductible equals the additional out-of-pocket cost if you have an accident. For example, if high deductible saves $200/year but costs $500 more per accident, you break even after 2.5 years without an accident, or if you have 0.4 accidents per year (one every 2.5 years).
  • How do I calculate deductible break-even?
    Divide annual premium savings by the deductible difference. For example, if high deductible saves $200/year and the deductible difference is $500, you need 0.4 accidents per year to break even (one accident every 2.5 years). This calculator does this automatically and factors in your accident likelihood.
  • What is a typical accident likelihood?
    Most drivers have a 2-10% annual probability of an at-fault accident. Young drivers (under 25) may have 10-20% likelihood. Experienced drivers with good records may have 2-5% likelihood. Your actual likelihood depends on driving history, age, location, and driving habits.
  • How much can I save with high deductible?
    High deductible typically saves 10-30% on premiums. For example, increasing deductible from $500 to $1,000 might save $100-300 per year depending on your policy, location, and driving record. The exact savings varies by insurer and individual factors.
  • What deductible amounts are common?
    Common deductibles are $250, $500, $1,000, and $2,500. Lower deductibles ($250-500) have higher premiums but lower out-of-pocket costs. Higher deductibles ($1,000-2,500) have lower premiums but higher out-of-pocket costs. Choose based on your ability to pay the deductible if needed.

Related Tools